v4n1 Layman on Brennan and JaworskiPosted: January 17, 2016 Filed under: Uncategorized Leave a comment
“Expressive Objections to Markets: Normative, Not Symbolic” by Daniel Layman
A COMMENTARY ON Jason Brennan and Peter Jaworski (2015), “Markets Without Symbolic Limits,” Ethics 125(4): 1053–1077
Jason Brennan and Peter Jaworski reject expressive objections to markets on the grounds that (1) market symbolism is culturally contingent, and (2) contingent cultural symbols are less important than the benefits markets offer. I grant (1) and (2), but I deny that these points suffice as grounds to dismiss expressive critiques of markets. For many plausible expressive critiques of markets are not symbolic critiques at all. Rather, they are critiques grounded in the idea that some market transactions embody morally inappropriate normative stances toward the goods or services on offer.
To download the full PDF, click here: Layman on Brennan and Jaworski.